Quantcast

The Road Not Taken

Charlotte’s streetcar squabble masks deeper questions about race and class



Dave Urban

Maybe Charlotte’s streetcar project is a good idea, maybe not. But it’s become the city’s most contentious political issue because it’s a stand-in for the land-mine subjects nobody, especially public officials, wants to discuss: race and class.

The streetcar would run 10 miles, starting near the Beatties Ford Road/I-85 intersection on the west side and running through uptown to Eastland Mall, essentially extending two transit arms from the city’s economic center to its poorest and most neglected areas at a total cost of $457 million. But there’s not enough money in the transit fund, and although Mayor Anthony Foxx has been a devoted cheerleader for the project, a majority of City Council has declined to raise property taxes to pay for the route’s first leg.

Community leaders and residents on the east and west sides think a city that’s spent millions on other parts of Charlotte, especially uptown, is dragging its feet in those areas because poor and minority voters lack sufficient clout. Whether that’s true, or intentional, or racially motivated—or motivated at all—is moot. There’s still little public investment on the east and west sides of town, while the rest of Charlotte gleams with new development—much of it boosted by taxpayer-funded improvements.

“I don’t think it’s a conscious thing. I’m not calling anybody racist. I just think they’re oblivious,” says state Senator Malcolm Graham, referring to opponents of the streetcar. Graham, who is black, is an outspoken advocate of the project and works at Johnson C. Smith University, which is backing the streetcar as a way to connect its campus to uptown. “For a lot of people, it’s more than just another project. It’s the symbolism of the city not supporting each and every side of town in equal measure.”

Uptown is nothing like what it was in the 1980s. NoDa, Plaza Midwood, and University City are growing by the minute, boosted by public investment of one kind or another, and the LYNX Blue Line is fertilizing the South Boulevard corridor as city planners had expected. Meanwhile, west and east Charlotte look more or less the same as they did 30 years ago.

So it’s hard to blame Foxx for pointing out the obvious during his State of the City address in February. He suggested that opposition to the streetcar project was based on “where it goes”: “There are people who live on Central Avenue and Beatties Ford Road who have as much ambition as someone in south Charlotte,” he said. Meaning: That ambition could blossom into reality if economic growth could meet it halfway.

It’s here that we wade into treacherous waters. Charlotte has become New South Inc. by electing several African Americans to public office and embracing some minority-owned businesses, such as the Walter B. Davis Company, a general contractor that helped manage construction of the NASCAR Hall of Fame, and Mert’s Heart and Soul, a soul-food restaurant that’s a fixture uptown. So questionable accusations of racism tend to elicit at least as much pushback as racism itself. But that doesn’t mean the perception of neglect in minority neighborhoods is invalid, and it’s no excuse for city leaders to avoid a difficult discussion about an inconvenient subject.

Of course there are budgetary concerns about the streetcar project, legitimate questions about the effective use of public money and whether it represents smart development or a white elephant. There always are.

But the people who control the money need to understand that two big parts of Charlotte have largely missed out on the civic upgrade. Until city leaders are willing to talk about the streetcar project openly and in good faith, it will continue to substitute for the real conversation they need to have about what Charlotte is willing to invest in, and whom, and where, and how much—and if not, why not.

Greg Lacour, a frequent contributor to this magazine, also blogs on politics at Poking the Hornet's Nest

 

More »Related Stories

Swimming with Coal Ash

Life around the corner from Charlotte’s biggest environmental threat

The Good, the Bad, and the Charlotte Way

Thoughts on the arrest of our mayor

Tales from the Home-Buying Trail

One squirrel, 15 cats, and a coupla hot chicks

A Neighborhood's Fate is Tied to the Future of Eastland Mall

Winterfield depends on the mall's redevelopment

We invite your responses and discussion. Please refrain from personal attacks, profanity, commercial promotion, or non sequiturs.

Add your comment:

Blogs »


Poking the Hornet's Nest

Greg Lacour on Politics

'Moral Movies' Series Launches in Charlotte, Other N.C. Cities

A Wilmington nonprofit launches a statewide film series to highlight education and economic issues. Tonight: 'American Teacher.'

Comments


Dusk Till Dawn

Jarvis Holliday Chronicles Charlotte's Nightlife and Social Scene, Straight No Chaser

Bachelorette Auction, Drex and Maney’s Party with Aloe Blacc, PlayDate Charlotte, Passport For Fashion, and More April 24-27

Charlotte’s social scene is jam packed with events over the next few days.

Comments


Revue

Andy Smith on Charlotte Arts & Culture

This Weekend in Charlotte (4/23/14): Gillian Welch, PostSecret, Othello, & Lady Antebellum

Comments


Charlotte at Home

Creating Your Space in the Queen City

5 Great DIY Projects

Home renovations, gardening tips, and a backyard bash to inspire your creative side

Comments


Dine & Dish

News, Notes, and Gossip About the Charlotte Restaurant Scene

Food (Truck) Fights

New rules could hurt the industry

Comments


Revue

Andy Smith on Charlotte Arts & Culture

Charlotte Magazine Cover Shoot Featured in Matrimony Video

Comments


Charlotte at Home

Creating Your Space in the Queen City

Apply for a Grant from Keep Charlotte Beautiful

The committee will award $5,000 for projects that make lasting impacts

Comments


Poking the Hornet's Nest

Greg Lacour on Politics

The Agenda 21 Derangement

How a wild conspiracy theory lassoes mainstream Republicans, Pat McCrory included.

Comments


Dine & Dish

News, Notes, and Gossip About the Charlotte Restaurant Scene

New Favorite Spring Side

Highlighting spring vegetables should be the highlight of your day, especially when its this

Comments


On Tap

Matt McKenzie on Craft Beer in Charlotte

A busy week in Charlotte craft beer with events by VBGB, JJ's Red Hots/Triple C, Custom Home Pubs/Unknown, Olde Mecklenburg and Birdsong

Comments


Poking the Hornet's Nest

Greg Lacour on Politics

McCrory's Coal Ash Proposal: All Sizes Fit One

Gov. McCrory's proposed coal ash legislation sounds like a strong step toward forcing Duke Energy to clean the stuff up. It's not. Here's why.

Comments


Dine & Dish

News, Notes, and Gossip About the Charlotte Restaurant Scene

Spring Feasts

Ham, matzah, lamb, potatoes, and eggs, oh my. Passover kicked off Monday and Easter is coming up, so I've got a meal plan ready for you if you've put it off till now.

Comments


Dine & Dish

News, Notes, and Gossip About the Charlotte Restaurant Scene

Coming This Fall: RockSalt

Owner Travis Croxton on his new space at Park Road Shopping Center, his family's oyster farm, and his love of Price's Chicken Coop

Comments


Charlotte at Home

Creating Your Space in the Queen City

Matthews Market Opens for Spring this Saturday

After a snowy winter and early spring cold snap, farmers and customers are eager to return

Comments


Dusk Till Dawn

Jarvis Holliday Chronicles Charlotte's Nightlife and Social Scene, Straight No Chaser

Nightlife News: Sydney’s Martini and Wine Bar Opens, Rebranding Leads to 3 Trade, and Dharma Lounge Prepares to Close

Keep up with the changing landscape in Charlotte’s nightlife scene.

Comments


On Tap

Matt McKenzie on Craft Beer in Charlotte

Charlotte’s first growler fill store to open this summer

Located in SouthEnd, The Beer Growler will have 45 taps

Comments


Dusk Till Dawn

Jarvis Holliday Chronicles Charlotte's Nightlife and Social Scene, Straight No Chaser

Springtime Events, ‘Illmatic’ Tribute Party, Cigars and Stilettos, Oak Room’s First Anniversary, and More April 17-20

The days leading up to Easter are quite eventful in Charlotte. Your social itinerary awaits.

Comments


Charlotte at Home

Creating Your Space in the Queen City

Carowinds in Bloom

The springtime festival continues through the weekend with flowers, cooking demos, and craft beer

Comments


Dine & Dish

News, Notes, and Gossip About the Charlotte Restaurant Scene

Sow Much Good

Providing fresh produce and farm goods to those in urban deserts, Sow Much Good has reopened

Comments


Revue

Andy Smith on Charlotte Arts & Culture

This Weekend in Charlotte (4/16/14): Blue Man Group, Springsteen, & Local Natives

Comments